Sunday, February 22, 2015

2014 MG Fiction Cybils Winner: Nickel Bay Nick by Dean Pitchford

Congratulations for Dean Pitchford on winning the 2014 Middle Grade Fiction Cybils award.  It was a pleasure to read all of the Round 2 MG contenders and a mighty tough decision for all of us.  It was also a pleasure to work for my fellow Round 2 MG judges: Terry Doherty (Family Bookshelf), Jennifer Donovan (5 Minutes for Books), Heidi Grange (Geo Librarian), Holly Mueller (Reading, Teaching, Learning) and of course, the MG coordinator Karen Yingling (Ms. Yingling Reads).  And thank you, Greg Pattridge (Always in the Middle) for nominating Nickel Bay Nick.

Sam Brattle may only be 11, but he has had quite a life already.  The recipient of a heart transplant as a baby, Sam's mother left and she has just remarried.  Sam and his dad don't get along, and to make matters worse, Sam's best friends are older and wild.  In fact, Sam has already acquired quite a list of offences.  Luckily for him, the police are old friends of his dad and never press charges.  But Sam's luck seems to run out on Christmas Day.  After being chased by the police for breaking windows in the condemned railway station, Sam decides to lose them by climbing an evergreen tree in the yard of an unfriendly neighbor.  But after the police passed him by, Sam slide down the tree after seeing a monstrous dog in a window, taking a lot of tree and Christmas decorations with him.

Now, Sam's life is about change.  Mr. Wells, who lives in the house and is a bit of a recluse, makes Sam an offer he can't refuse - after all, he did cause a lot of expensive property damage.  It seems that Nickel Bay is a pretty depressed town, with lots of closed businesses, even Sam's dad is having money trouble with his bakery.  And this year, no one out hustling and bustling to get their Christmas shopping done.  In the past, a Good Samaritan nicknamed Nickel Bay Nick had secretly left $100 for the town's residents just before Christmas, but this year there was not Nick.

It seems Mr. Wells was actually Nickel Bay Nick and he had broken his leg so he couldn't get around.  His proposition to Sam: tell his father he is working off his debt by doing some filing for Mr. Wells.  Meantime, Mr. Wells come up with the idea that for the 12 days of Christmas, between December 25th and January 6th, Sam with train and become that year's Nickel Bay Nick.  Can such a preposterous idea really work?  Maybe.

When I first started to read Nickel Bay Nick, I wasn't too sure I was going to like it.  Sam seemed like a really unpleasant character and since the story is told in his voice, all the reader has is his perspective - not good with an unlikable character.  But as I read along, I was pleasantly surprised to discover that this was really a fun book to read, after all, simply because things are not what they seem to be at first.

Sam is really not a bad kid, but is a misguided one.  He has a lot to learn, but this is a coming of age novel, so, yes, he does learn the right lessons that change his life.  But it is the process of coming of age that makes this such an interesting book.  It is a well written book, with just the right balance of humor and poignancy, and in between that, there's plenty of excitement, especially when Sam goes out at night to deliver his envelopes of money.

As an adult reader, I found bits in this novel a little contrived, maybe there was just too much coincidence, and certainly, with all he has done wrong, there should have been consequences for Sam at some point regardless of past friendships but I know that as a kid reader I wouldn't have minded any of that, and I'm betting kids today won't either.

Nickel Bay Nick is a satisfying novel that not only entertains, but shows us the feel good benefits to helping others.  After all, this is a book with a lot of heart - real hearts, transplanted hearts, kind hearts and misguided hearts.
Once again, congratulations on winning the 2014 MG Cybils award.

This book is recommended for readers age 9+
This book was bought for my personal library

Marvelous Middle Grade Monday is a weekly meme hosted by Shannon Messenger at Books, Ramblings and Plenty of Shenanigans




10 comments:

  1. I was pleased to nominate this book. Certainly my favorite from last year. You summed it up beautifully in your last paragraph. Also, thanks to the esteemed panel's hard work on the CYBILS this year.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Greg, because to your nomination, I got to read a great book I might not have found on my own. That's one of the good parts of being a Cybils judge.

      Delete
  2. This sounds so interesting. I love it when characters turn out to be a little different than what I expected.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is very interesting. I like characters that are a little different than they appear to be also, and this book fits that bill completely.

      Delete
  3. This is not in stock at Baker and Taylor! So bummed. Apparently, they aren't reprinting the hardcover because the paperback is doing well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They do that now. I've learned if I really like it and want to own it, buy fast. Too bad, but nowadays 2nd printings are few and far between.

      Delete
  4. Wow, this sounds like a good one! I'll have to check it out!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, it is a good one. Hope you enjoy it.

      Delete
  5. I was intrigued by the fact that "things aren't as they seem." I find it hard to get into books with an unlikeable narrator, but it sounds like the payoff at the end is worth it. Thanks for the rec!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Actually I only meant that when something is introduced in the story, they aren't what Sam thought they were, including himself. He goes through very nice changes. I don't know that Sam is a true unreliable narrator, but he certainly isn't in possession of all the facts - they come out in the story and even Sam get surprised. It's fun, not draggy or boring.

      Delete

 
Imagination Designs